Untethered Teachers: Using AppleTV in the Classroom

larryreiff —  March 14, 2012 — 50 Comments

By Larry Reiff

Is it possible to be both a wired and unwired educator at the same time? Sounds like someone trying to explain Schrödinger’s cat (the cat is both alive and dead at the same time, Google it).  I’m talking about being “an untethered teacher.”  Sometimes, we end up tethered to the technology in our classroom.  To me, this is most evident with the interactive white board at the front of my classroom (I’ve intentionally omitted any particular brand name devices). Fortunately, I’ve been using AppleTV to untether myself from the front of the room.

I’ve spoken to a lot of administrators about what they look for when performing teacher observations.  One of the comments I heard over and over again was, “I want to see the teacher circulating among the students.”  You can’t do that if you’re attached to the interactive white board.  I have an AppleTV in my classroom hooked up to a projector.  Using my iPad and AirPlay, I can wirelessly mirror any content on my iPad to the screen at the front of the room. The real advantage is evident during collaborative activities.  Students can use their own iOS devices to connect to the AppleTV  to share their work with the rest of the class.  I can be anywhere in the room and still run my lesson.  I can pull up sound and video clips on my iPad and instantly share them with my class without being attached to any particular location in the room.

The cost savings are incredible.  Most interactive white boards cost between $2500-$3500 per unit.  That cost doesn’t include the man hours for installation.  You can purchase an iPad, a projector, and an AppleTV for under $1000. Hooking up an AppleTV is remarkably simple. The unit has two wires, a power cord and HDMI connection.  (If your projector doesn’t have HDMI, converters are available for about $25.) There is no software to install and the unit is completely portable.  I carry mine from class to class and set it up in about 1 minute.  As long as they are both connected to the same wireless network, the iPad and AppleTV work seamlessly together.

The truth is that most teachers aren’t using interactive white boards to their full potential; they are being used a projectors for PowerPoint presentations.  The wealth of apps available for the iPad overwhelmingly exceeds the functions of more expensive solutions.  I use Keynote for all of my presentations. When teaching about the civil rights era, I’m able to use the iPod app to play speeches my Dr. Martin Luther King.  We use iAnnotate to mark up documents and share our notes with the class.  YouTube videos can be pulled up quickly along with playlists.  When teaching Shakespeare, I’m able to show the class three different actors delivering the same soliloquy.  There is no lag time.  I can show different video clips without pausing to swap out DVDs or look for files in the computer at the front of the room.  If I have it in iTunes or on my iPad, I can share it with my students. Every teachers knows that downtime is the enemy.  Think about how quickly you can switch between apps on your iPad.  With an AppleTV, you never need to walk to computer or the board to move between activities. Double tapping the home button brings you to all of your running apps.    Lessons just flow more smoothly since I started using it in my classroom.

In August, Apple will release a software update to its current operating system, Lion.  When Mountain Lion is released this summer, users will have the ability to mirror their iMac and MacBook desktops to AppleTV.  No more cables to connect.

The list of advantages goes on.  Instant access to iTunes U content.  No more need for a document camera.  Quite simply, if you can do it on your iPad, you can share it with your class.  For $99, it’s worth experimenting with.

“lorrain croy” lorrain croy 

larryreiff

Posts Twitter

  • http://twitter.com/Jon_Torbitt Jonathan

    You can achieve something similar using Keynote and Keynote remote, which does require a Macbook of some sort (or Mac Mini) connected to the projector. You still have to go through the hassle of making keynotes but you don’t need an interactive whiteboard either.

  • Ryan (@Ryan_Fisk)

    Larry,

    Great write up, but most of your examples stem around using AirPlay mirroring, which is only one of many Apple TV features. Do you foresee Apple releasing a “barebones” version of the TV that acts ONLY as a wireless dongle for AirPlay mirroring? That’d be great!

  • Elearning mentor.

    We use a Mac book air connected to our IWB, with the $15 reflection app we can project any iPad in the room. Even cheaper!

    • Ascienceteacher

      Will this work with a regular macbook?

  • Pingback: Untethered Teachers: Using AppleTV in the Classroom | Wired Educator « RobertZwick.Com

  • Pingback: A Twitter Visit “In Real Life” – My Time with @NMHS_Principal « Dov Emerson's As Of Yet Untitled Blog

  • Pingback: Technology in… Education: Unwiring Teachers

  • Graeme Campbell

    Do you have any experience with those connectors from HDMI -> ? Everything I’ve read says that they can’t be used with an apple TV….

    • Matt Baier

      We have an HDMI to VGA adapter that has been working fine for us with appleTV and our “old” projectors.

      • Ascienceteacher

        Where did you get your HDMI to VGA adapter? I would like to try this set up, but I don’t know where to get the adapter.

      • Jamiehade1

        Matt – are you using the cable HDMI toVGA or are you running from a box?

    • Larry Reiff
      • Ascienceteacher

        Larry – Thank you for the link. I have been looking for the correct converter box and your link was very helpful. I plan on ordering one today and getting things set up. Thanks for your help!

  • Rprowse123

    What about sound when connecting to the projector connected to a smart board ?

    • Larry Reiff

      The adapter I use has R/L outputs. I just plug audio wires from those outputs to a set of speakers

    • Melanie Calhoun

      You can also use Bluetooth speakers.

  • http://twitter.com/NathanSandberg Nathan Sandberg

    I really love this idea of using the Apple TV to free yourself from the front of the room. This is something that I have wanted to do for a while but just have never gotten around to it. Are you using an iPad 1 or 2?

    • Larry Reiff

      iPad 2

  • Karlajayne

    We are unable to use Apple TV in my district at this time due to our network, it’s security and safety controls do not allow the Apple TV and iPad to recognize each other as being on the same wifi connection. Our IT guy found this out the hard way while trying to set it up. At this time, we can’t find a way to use it without compromising our Internet security. Has anyone found a way around this problem?

    • Jayemtucker

      The same problem happened when I tried to connect my iPad 2 to my MacBook Pro using AirServer (installed on my laptop) both in our lab on the BGSU campus and at one school where I tried it; I was on the same network both times. I work for an ed tech agency that does PD for K-12 schools in NW Ohio. I was told their network and/or routers are set up to disallow them to recognize each other. It works like a charm on my home WiFi network.

      The same difficulties happen on a irregular basis with the assessment app eClicker. Sometimes it works and sometimes it doesn’t. I have had NO difficulties with the Socrative assessment app.

      jt

    • Tim

      One solution is to bring a wifi router and have your *own* wireless network… though this would be sans internet. That’s my plan…

      • DaveAdmin

        Tim, If you brought your own wireless network into my enterprise network, as soon as you plugged it in it would be turned off by security settings on the wireless network. This is not a credible solution.

    • http://hinghamschools.com/FOS/departments/artroom/ArtRoom/Blog/Entries/2012/4/30_iPad_and_Reflection_App.html Cmckeon

      My network was also an issue and is protected – I purchased Reflection, then “created a network” from my iMac, (which uses Bonjour/Bluetooth) and had my iPad connect to that network. I can wirelessly connect that way. See my Blog entry dated April 30th, 2011 for a complete “how to.” http://hinghamschools.com/FOS/departments/artroom/ArtRoom/Blog/Entries/2012/4/30_iPad_and_Reflection_App.html

    • Greg

      Same at our school. No work around found yet.

    • Tim Goree

      We’ve solved this problem at the enterprise network level. We have Ruckus wireless access points, and with those (as well as other modern aps) you can setup different interfaces on the same access point. We setup a special network interface on the access points that only the Apple TVs and presentation iPads connect to that allows the peer to peer networking that those devices need to work together. While it doesn’t allow student iPads on this interface to take over the screen, we feel this is a decent compromise to making the teacher presentation experience clean and secure. For students to take over and present, I would use the Reflection App on a laptop that the teacher controls. The teacher can switch the TV or projector over to the laptop input when they want the students to take over and be seen.

  • Adamsm

    We have network constraints, but I do have an Apple TV hooked to a HD TV in my school library and I use it with my K-4 students. I LOVE it! and so do they. To be able to walk among them, or pass the iPad around and have them be the teacher is fantastic. We are hopefully going to get some much needed tech upgrades soon, and the uses are unlimited.

  • Pingback: Diigo Links (weekly)

  • Pingback: Första tankarna om att blogga « Hagenzz's Blog

  • Ascienceteacher

    We have wanted to do this at our school but when I contacted APPLE to get the necessary cables etc. they told me that appletv only works on HDTVs. Apparently they are wrong, but I need to know exactly what cables I will need for my projector since it does not have a HDMI imput. Can you help me? Thanks

    • Larry Reiff

      It definitely works, I have it set up in my classroom right now using a Monoprice HDMI to VGA & R/L Stereo Audio Converter. You’ll may need a splitter depending on what type of speakers you have. The HDMI to VGA adapter only has R/L output.

    • Kash Khetia

      You will need an HDMI to VGA converter for using your Apple TV2/3 to get the full 1080p in class-rooms with audio, i saw one at the CUE conference recently in Palm Springs from a company called Kanex, they have the solution.

  • Pingback: A Twitter Visit “In Real Life” – My Time with @NMHS_Principal | Connected Principals

  • Pingback: New Apps to Try « Ggosse's Blog

  • Brett Boessen

    This is a great extension of the capabilities of these tools — very nice work. :) Gonna talk to my IT staff tomorrow!

  • Tim

    What relatively inexpensive projectors do you guys reccomend for this? I need to take it with me, class to class, and project onto chalkboards/whiteboards…

  • Ggosse

    “The truth is that most teachers aren’t using interactive white boards to their full potential”
    I don’t think this is accurate. Those teachers that are even thinking about apple tv in their room are the teachers that have fully utilize their interactive boards. They are the tech savoy ones.
    It’s nor all glory either..I have seen lots of lag with airplay when it comes to video. Video is much more demanding.

  • Northernbelle65

    Which model of HD television works best with Apple TV.

  • Anhudgins

    So help me out here…is this the complete list of items i need?

    1. Ipad

    2. wifi internet

    3. apple tv

    4. projector (http://www.amazon.com/ViewSonic-PJD5123-Projector-120Hz-Lumens/dp/B004UG3BQK/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&qid=1338312547&sr=8-3)

    5. HDMI cord to connect apple tv and projector

    6. Blue tooth Speakers? (what if the projector has speakers?)

    7. Regular white board

  • Christy

    There must also b a wireless access point in your classroom or it drops the connection frequently. I had this set up in my classroom but had to abandon it because the wap was in the hall & I wasted too much class time reconnecting.

  • Hank

    Thanks for the article. I use an EPSON BrightLink 450Wi in my classroom, which takes up a huge portion of the front wall of the classroom. I can access the web with my MacBook pro or iPad, , show DVDs through a DVD player, and even use some of my favorite old movies & documentaries through a still-functioning VHS player.

    With all of these resources, what does an Apple TV offer that I can’t get now?
    Hank

  • Pingback: Apple TV plus iTunes Match and Photostream « Teaching with iPad

  • http://twitter.com/Appledystopia Appledystopia

    I just added some tips on AirPlay, including how to prevent crashes. You can read about it on my blog, Appledystopia. Nice AppleTV 2 photo, btw ;-)

  • http://twitter.com/m_5aleds Mohammed Khaled

    It really worth trying this amazing device. I have a serious problem with it; the security issue; I know you can set up a password but the problem is once you give the student the password you wont be able to remove it from his iPad. So we can say its MDM (Mobile device Management)’s problem. I’ve tried hard to find a solution for this small issue but I got tiered. your immediate help on this regards is highly appreciated.

  • http://twitter.com/IanMcVitty Ian McVitty

    I really like this idea, since when I go from class to class it takes up to 15 minutes to turn on PC, login, login to BlackBoard, Open POwerPoint load that, while my students are waiting and watching.
    If the room could be set up with all the cables and adaptors you describe and all I needed to do was open the iPad, I could be more productive and the idea of being untethered is the principle benefit here.
    Would ITS allow this to happen? I very much doubt it, but I will ask.

  • Pingback: » Doceri + Apple TV = New Solutions for the Classroom Freedom to Teach – the Doceri Blog

  • Fs

    I was excited about going wireless as a teacher but found the apple tv would not connect to any of the tech in my classroom due to the hdmi only output. I even purchased and hdmi to RCA work around. No go :( . Finally had to return it. I am hopeful that the “AirBridge” by artifex tech will be funded on kickstarter!

  • Pingback: Lots of Links… To Be Sorted « Teach Tech Ed